NCA ECC vs OTCC: Which Cybersecurity Controls Apply to You?

The National Cybersecurity Authority (NCA) requires the Essential Cybersecurity Controls (ECC) for government entities and private organisations that own, operate, or host critical national infrastructure (CNI). The Operational Technology Cybersecurity Controls (OTCC) extend this baseline to industrial control systems in...

  • November 17, 2026
  • 12Mins
Operational technology and IT cybersecurity shield for industrial and corporate compliance in Saudi Arabia

The National Cybersecurity Authority (NCA) requires the Essential Cybersecurity Controls (ECC) for government entities and private organisations that own, operate, or host critical national infrastructure (CNI). The Operational Technology Cybersecurity Controls (OTCC) extend this baseline to industrial control systems in critical facilities. ECC compliance comes first, followed by OTCC where applicable.

This guide helps compliance, cybersecurity, and operational technology (OT) teams in Saudi Arabia identify the applicable controls. It explains the differences, facility levels, and practical implementation steps.

If your organisation needs structured guidance on the baseline requirements, consider the NCA ECC Course (Saudi Arabia) to support your compliance preparation.

NCA ECC vs OTCC at a Glance

NCA ECC vs OTCC cybersecurity compliance comparison illustration - Saudi Compliance Institute

NCA ECC and OTCC address different but connected cybersecurity needs. ECC establishes the baseline for entities within its scope, while OTCC adds requirements for operational technology in critical facilities. Your organisation's status, systems, and facility criticality determine which controls apply.

Comparison

ECC

OTCC

Full name

Essential Cybersecurity Controls

Operational Technology Cybersecurity Controls

Issuer

National Cybersecurity Authority

National Cybersecurity Authority

Current edition

ECC-2:2024

OTCC-1:2022

Structure

4 domains, 28 subdomains, 108 main controls, 92 subcontrols

4 domains, 23 subdomains, 47 main controls, 122 subcontrols

Prerequisite

Baseline requirements for entities in scope

ECC compliance

Primary focus

Organisation-wide cybersecurity

Industrial control systems and OT security

Criticality model

Organisational scope and control applicability

Critical-facility levels L1, L2, and L3

Mandatory scope

Government entities and private entities owning, operating, or hosting CNI

Relevant critical ICS facilities within the specified government and CNI scope

Sources: NCA Essential Cybersecurity Controls and NCA Operational Technology Cybersecurity Controls.

The key distinction: ECC and OTCC are not alternatives. Organisations subject to OTCC must first meet the ECC baseline, then implement the applicable OTCC requirements.

What Is NCA ECC? 

NCA ECC stands for National Cybersecurity Authority Essential Cybersecurity Controls. These controls establish minimum cybersecurity requirements for Saudi government entities and private organisations that own, operate, or host CNI. The current edition is ECC-2:2024.

What does ECC-2:2024 cover?

The current framework organises cybersecurity requirements into four main domains:

  • Cybersecurity governance: policies, responsibilities, risk management, and compliance.

  • Cybersecurity defence: protection of assets, identities, networks, systems, and information.

  • Cybersecurity resilience: business continuity and resilience requirements.

  • Third-party and cloud computing cybersecurity: supplier relationships, cloud services, and hosting.

ECC-2:2024 contains 4 domains, 28 subdomains, 108 main controls, and 92 subcontrols. Its requirements address governance and technical safeguards across the organisation. The NCA also publishes an ECC implementation guide to help entities implement the requirements.

Who must comply with NCA ECC?

The ECC scope includes government agencies in Saudi Arabia, their affiliated companies and entities inside or outside the Kingdom, and private-sector organisations that own, operate, or host CNI. The NCA encourages other organisations to adopt the controls as good practice.

Organisations should assess applicability against their legal status, operations, and technology use. For example, subdomain 4-2 applies to entities that use or plan to use cloud computing and hosting services.

Read the detailed guidance on who must comply with NCA ECC before deciding whether your organisation falls within scope.

What changed from ECC-1:2018?

ECC-2:2024 replaced the previous ECC-1:2018 edition. The newer version has four main domains instead of five. It contains 108 main controls and 92 subcontrols, compared with 114 controls across five domains in ECC-1:2018.

Most importantly, the former Domain 5, Industrial Control Systems Cybersecurity, was removed. Its controls moved to OTCC, as explained in Appendix C of ECC-2:2024. Therefore, organisations should not use the old ECC structure to determine current OT obligations.

What Is NCA OTCC?

The Operational Technology Cybersecurity Controls (OTCC-1:2022) are NCA requirements designed to protect industrial control systems in critical facilities. They extend ECC with additional safeguards for operational environments where cybersecurity incidents can affect service availability, safety, and essential operations.

How is OTCC structured?

OTCC-1:2022 contains:

  • 4 main domains

  • 23 subdomains

  • 47 main controls

  • 122 subcontrols

Like ECC, it follows four pillars: Strategy, People, Process, and Technology. However, its requirements address OT-specific risks and operating conditions.

Who must comply with OTCC?

OTCC applies to industrial control systems in facilities deemed critical and owned or operated by government bodies or private entities that own, operate, or host CNI. The stated scope also covers relevant facilities in the Kingdom or abroad.

Other organisations are strongly encouraged to adopt OTCC, but encouragement should not be confused with a mandatory requirement. Organisations must determine their actual scope using the official OTCC document and supporting materials.

What are the four OTCC pillars?

OTCC follows the same four cybersecurity pillars as ECC:

  1. Strategy: establish direction and oversight.

  2. People: define responsibilities and build relevant capability.

  3. Process: formalise risk management and operational procedures.

  4. Technology: implement safeguards for OT assets and networks.

These pillars connect governance with technical implementation. However, OTCC applies them to industrial environments with operational constraints.

Key Differences Between ECC and OTCC

Comparison diagram of ECC and OTCC cybersecurity frameworks showing scope, criticality model, control style, and safety clauses

ECC focuses on the organisation's cybersecurity baseline. OTCC addresses the additional risks of critical operational technology. Although their structures share four pillars, their scope, criticality assessment, and technical requirements differ.

Scope and applicability

ECC applies according to the organisation's status and applicable controls. OTCC applies to relevant ICS within critical facilities covered by its scope.

For example, a government ministry without industrial operations may need ECC without OTCC. A CNI operator running a critical industrial facility may need both.

Criticality model

ECC applicability depends on organisational scope and the technologies used. OTCC adds a facility-level assessment to determine which control level applies to a critical facility.

This distinction matters because an organisation should not automatically assign the same OTCC level to every facility. Separate, isolated facilities may have different levels when their critical systems and impacts differ.

Control style

ECC establishes organisation-wide requirements for governance, defence, resilience, and third-party or cloud security. OTCC adds safeguards tailored to industrial control systems, including network segmentation, restricted remote access, and protection of Safety Instrumented Systems.

Consequently, a general IT security policy may not demonstrate that OTCC requirements are implemented in a plant environment.

The safety clause is not an exemption

OTCC recognises that applying a control must not jeopardise operational continuity. However, this provision does not give organisations blanket permission to skip requirements.

If an organisation cannot apply a control safely, it must document the justification and obtain the specified approvals. Any risk acceptance must include approved alternative controls for a defined period and continuous reassessment.

How ECC and OTCC Work Together

ECC and OTCC Cybersecurity Compliance Framework Roadmap Diagram by Saudi Compliance Institute

ECC compliance is the prerequisite for OTCC implementation. Organisations should establish their ECC baseline first, then assess critical facilities and apply the relevant OTCC requirements. This sequence follows the OTCC Methodology and Mapping Annex.

Other NCA standards may also apply, depending on the organisation and its systems.

Framework

Primary purpose

ECC-2:2024

Organisation-wide cybersecurity baseline

OTCC-1:2022

Cybersecurity for OT and ICS in critical facilities

CSCC-1:2019

Additional requirements for critical systems

CCC-2:2024

Cloud cybersecurity

DCC

Data cybersecurity controls

Critical IT systems fall under the relevant CSCC requirements. Critical OT and ICS are addressed through OTCC, while cloud use may trigger applicable CCC requirements. Data-related obligations should also be assessed against DCC and other relevant rules.

Organisations comparing regulatory controls with a broader management standard can also review NCA ECC vs ISO 27001 to understand the different purposes of these frameworks.

If your team needs practical support applying the ECC baseline, the NCA ECC Course (Saudi Arabia) can help structure learning around the relevant requirements.

OTCC Facility Levels: How Many Controls Apply to You?

OTCC uses three facility levels to determine the applicable control requirements. The facility takes the level of its most critical system, based on the prescribed impact criteria. Organisations should use the official methodology and mapping annex rather than assigning levels informally.

Facility level

Number of controls and subcontrols

Meaning

L1

151

Includes the requirements for L2 and L3

L2

117

Includes the requirements for L3

L3

56

The lowest of the three facility levels

These totals represent the stated level requirements, not the OTCC document's total number of controls. OTCC contains 47 main controls and 122 subcontrols across its framework.

How is a facility level identified?

The OTCC methodology considers three impact dimensions:

  • Availability of the service.

  • Health, safety, and environmental consequences.

  • Impact on the national economy, security, or society.

The Facility Level Identification Tool uses nine criteria listed in the methodology annex. The most critical system determines the facility's level. Separate facilities may receive different levels if they are isolated and their critical systems differ.

The NCA also encourages organisations to apply controls above their assigned level where appropriate. For the official requirements, consult the OTCC document and the OTCC Methodology and Mapping Annex.

Which Controls Apply to You? A Simple Decision Path

Your organisation's status, critical systems, and operational technology determine the applicable NCA controls. Start with ECC scope, then assess whether critical ICS facilities require OTCC. Finally, determine the facility level and check other relevant frameworks.

  1. Are you a government entity or a CNI owner, operator, or host? Assess mandatory ECC applicability first.

  2. Do you operate ICS in a critical facility? If OTCC applies, establish ECC compliance before implementing OTCC.

  3. What facility level applies? Use the official identification methodology to determine L1, L2, or L3.

  4. Do you use cloud services? Assess applicable CCC requirements and review third-party and cloud security controls in ECC

  5. Do you operate critical IT systems? Assess CSCC requirements separately. Critical OT and ICS follow OTCC where applicable.

Examples of how the decision works

Organisation scenario

Likely control direction

Ministry without an industrial plant

ECC, with other applicable controls assessed separately

Utility or refinery operating a critical facility

ECC first, followed by OTCC and facility-level assessment

Manufacturer supplying a CNI operator

Assess its own regulatory scope and contractual cybersecurity obligations

Private company outside direct ECC scope and not operating CNI

Assess applicable obligations, including NCNICC-1:2025 where notified; OTCC adoption is encouraged where relevant

A supplier does not automatically become directly subject to every NCA framework because it serves a CNI operator. Contractual requirements may nevertheless impose cybersecurity obligations. Organisations should review the contract, applicable notifications, and regulatory scope before deciding.

For private non-CNI entities, verify NCNICC-1:2025 requirements against the official NCA document. Its applicability should not be assumed without checking the relevant notification and scope.

What OTCC Asks for in Practice

OTCC translates industrial cybersecurity objectives into specific requirements for network architecture, remote access, safety systems, and operational protection. Organisations should map each applicable requirement to technical safeguards, responsible owners, and evidence of implementation.

Segmentation and the DMZ jump host

Control 2-4-1-9 prohibits direct corporate-to-OT traffic and requires a hardened jump host in the demilitarised zone (DMZ). Control 2-4-1-11 requires proxies for machine-to-machine traffic.

These requirements help restrict connections between business networks and industrial environments. Teams should document network paths and verify that the actual architecture matches the approved design.

Remote access as the exception

Control 2-2-1-7 restricts remote access to OT and permits it only as an exception. The organisation must complete a risk assessment first, use multifactor authentication and an encrypted channel, limit privileges and duration, and monitor and record sessions.

Related controls also address remote access through the DMZ. Organisations should review access permissions regularly and remove unnecessary standing connections.

Safety Instrumented Systems as a separate asset class

Safety Instrumented Systems (SIS) require appropriate protection and separation. Control 2-4-1-3 addresses SIS segmentation, while control 2-3-1-5 addresses keeping SIS controllers in appropriate modes.

Operational teams must assess cybersecurity safeguards alongside process safety and continuity requirements. If a control cannot be applied safely, it requires documented justification and the specified approval process.

OTCC also requires centralised, offline backups for OT assets under control 2-8-1-1. Control 2-11-1-6 requires all remote sessions to be monitored. These measures support recovery and visibility across operational environments.

Common Mistakes When Choosing Between ECC and OTCC

Incorrect scoping can leave important requirements unaddressed. Avoid these five common mistakes:

  • Treating ECC and OTCC as alternatives: OTCC implementation starts after ECC compliance.

  • Assigning facility levels casually: use the official methodology and assess the most critical system.

  • Leaving vendor VPNs permanently enabled: restrict remote access and apply the required safeguards.

  • Assuming ECC-2:2024 still contains an ICS domain: Domain 5 was removed, and its controls moved to OTCC.

  • Treating the safety clause as an exemption: document the justification, obtain approvals, and assess approved alternatives.

Review these points during the initial gap assessment. This helps prevent outdated interpretations from influencing the compliance plan.

Practical Roadmap: From Gap Assessment to Audit Readiness

6-Step Cybersecurity Compliance Process Infographic by Saudi Compliance Institute

An effective NCA compliance roadmap connects applicable controls with implementation evidence. Start with scope, establish ownership, and assess gaps before prioritising remediation. Then validate the controls and prepare for assessment.

  1. Confirm scope: document the organisation's status, CNI involvement, facilities, and relevant systems.

  2. Establish the ECC baseline: assess applicable ECC-2:2024 requirements and record existing evidence.

  3. Assess OTCC applicability: identify critical facilities and assign levels using the official methodology.

  4. Perform a control gap assessment: map each requirement to existing safeguards, gaps, owners, and actions.

  5. Implement and validate: address network segmentation, remote access, safety systems, and other applicable requirements.

  6. Prepare evidence and reviews: maintain approved documents, test results, risk decisions, and remediation records.

The NCA publishes an OTCC implementation guide and an Assessment and Compliance Tool to support implementation and assessment. The OTCC cybersecurity function must review the controls at least annually, while independent review is required at least every three years.

If your team is establishing its ECC baseline before moving to OTCC, the NCA ECC Course (Saudi Arabia) can support a more structured approach to understanding the requirements.

Frequently Asked Questions

Find quick answers to frequently asked questions. Can't find what you're looking for?

Start by confirming the organisation's scope and identifying applicable controls in ECC-2:2024. Assign control owners, assess existing safeguards, document gaps, and retain implementation evidence. The NCA's Guide to Essential Cybersecurity Controls (ECC) Implementation provides official implementation guidance.

There is no single universally mandated set of seven cybersecurity pillars. Different models organise cybersecurity principles differently. For NCA ECC and OTCC, the specified pillars are Strategy, People, Process, and Technology. Organisations should follow the terminology and structure in the applicable NCA control document.

The five Cs are not a defined set of pillars in the NCA ECC or OTCC documents. Other educational models may use that phrase differently. For NCA compliance, use the four stated pillars: Strategy, People, Process, and Technology, and map requirements to the relevant controls.

Yes, but remote access is restricted and permitted only as an exception under control 2-2-1-7. Organisations must complete a risk assessment, use multifactor authentication and encryption, restrict privileges and duration, and monitor and record sessions. Related controls impose additional safeguards for DMZ-based access.

OTCC applies to ICS in critical facilities within the specified scope of government bodies and private entities that own, operate, or host CNI. Other organisations are strongly encouraged to adopt the controls. Confirm applicability using the official OTCC document and its methodology annex.

The applicable level determines the total: L1 includes 151 controls and subcontrols, L2 includes 117, and L3 includes 56. The most critical system determines the facility's level. Use the official Facility Level Identification Tool methodology rather than choosing a level based solely on organisational preference.

No, the safety clause is not a blanket exemption. If applying a control could jeopardise operational continuity, the organisation must document its justification and obtain approval from the cybersecurity function and Authorizing Official. Risk acceptance requires approved alternative controls for a defined period and continuous reassessment.